Fish Explorer Logo
Colorado Fishing
Colorado Fishing  
Login Usr:Psd:
Don't have an account? Register now...
spacer spacer
Go back to Main FxR Forum listings

That one lure that has never caught a fish

Post By: ass bass or cash      Posted: 5/14/2020 8:02:36 PM     Points: 1730    
Go through your tackle and you're sure to find that one lure that has never caught a fish. Here's my choice. Post a pic of yours! Maybe someone will be able to tell you how/where to fish it or if they've had better luck.

I like multispecies lures and have have caught fish on everything else in my tackle box but try as I may, this lure has never gotten so much as a sniff. Fast, slow, like a spoon, nothing. Anyone else had any luck?
 Reply by: MALLEN      Posted: May. 14, 8:09:17 PM     Points: 44    
It needs a swivel on it. I always have kids use them, to catch fish
 Reply by: Goosehunter82      Posted: May. 14, 8:24:43 PM     Points: 53634    
That's a tough one. My problem is I have my half dozen "go to" lures, jigs or harnesses and that all I use even though I haul an arsonal with me. Mine would probably be a jigging rap. I try them every winter but never have any luck on them. I truly could pick 2 jigs, 2 spoons and 2 crawler harnesses and fish them all year catching everything I target plus the stockers I avoid.
 Reply by: skiman      Posted: May. 14, 8:25:13 PM     Points: 2326    
Agree with MALLEN on the swivel, and Iíd like to add, itís all in the retrieve. Try to get the best action going, and Iím sure youíll hook up.
 Reply by: JIGORNAUT      Posted: May. 14, 8:26:03 PM     Points: 321    
Thatís my go to lure, I canít believe youíve never caught anything on it.
 Reply by: ass bass or cash      Posted: May. 14, 8:42:30 PM     Points: 1730    
Goose, I agree. I gravitate to using only a handful of lures and a couple color senko's most of the year. But they're all so pretty to look at aren't they? I'm s sucker for a good looking lure.

Mallen/Ski/Jig - tried it all. This one's cursed!
 Reply by: bron      Posted: May. 14, 8:47:56 PM     Points: 36517    
Ive caught pleny fish on a jigging rap. I cannot figure out the bubble and fly thing on a spinning rod. Good with the flyrod but the bubble thing does not work for me.
 Reply by: not too old to fish      Posted: May. 14, 9:01:19 PM     Points: 5127    
Ass Bass, I have one of those in my tackle box and like you I've never caught anything on it.
 Reply by: Toadfish      Posted: May. 14, 9:08:01 PM     Points: 3794    
Goose, I love jigging raps up at Green Mountain for lakers. Never anything huge, but the hammer handles love it if you put a piece of sucker meat about the size of your thumbnail on the treble and jig high with it. I usually jig it 3-5í at a time and get hit while itís fluttering back down.

Bron, the trick to a fly and bubble is to make sure your fly is trailing the bubble. The easiest way to do that is to cast it out and let it sit for about 30 seconds, then give your rod a jerk like youíre using a jerk bait. That gets the line off the water and makes sure your fly is trailing your bubble far enough back.

Itís going to sound silly, and since my tackle got jacked I canít post a pic, but what I have always had trouble with are soft plastics... Iíve got the pitch etc. down, I just never seem to get a bite if Iím fishing a soft plastic.
 Reply by: Ryan      Posted: May. 14, 9:16:30 PM     Points: 2171    
That first lure (we always called them a Domino) caught a ton of fish for me in North Park growing up. Wonder if they still make them? I don't think I have one in my tackle box.
 Reply by: FishHuntNow      Posted: May. 14, 9:34:49 PM     Points: 40    
No one is going to believe me when I say the super duper catches Lakers in good numbers.

My lure that never catches me a thing is the dare devil.
 Reply by: ass bass or cash      Posted: May. 14, 9:49:19 PM     Points: 1730    
Ryan try
[log in for link]
Or you can have this cursed hunk a metal for free!
 Reply by: ass bass or cash      Posted: May. 14, 9:53:56 PM     Points: 1730    
Fish Hunt Now - Red/white daredevil is a classic bass and trout magnet. Yours is cursed. I know that feeling.
 Reply by: FishHuntNow      Posted: May. 14, 10:02:58 PM     Points: 40    
Haha, I have seen family and friends catch especially pike right next to me on the DD so mine is definitely cursed.
 Reply by: anglerwannabe      Posted: May. 16, 4:26:35 PM     Points: 56749    
this one.. and it's maddening. It has everything to be a great lure. Jointed, serious wobble, great wake.. color that should annoy pike to crushing it.. or LMB.. but thus far not even one hit

Nate.. talk to me buddy.. soft plastics are awesome.
 Reply by: Street Chub      Posted: May. 16, 4:43:14 PM     Points: 260    
Are you kidding me? "That ONE lure"! This makes me wonder if I might have some kind of miniature gypsy fortune teller living in my tackle box. I cast a lure, she casts a curse!
 Reply by: Pathway      Posted: May. 16, 5:55:15 PM     Points: 534    
I can teach you how to fish but I can't hook them for you. Very few lures that can't catch fish.
 Reply by: johnski      Posted: May. 16, 8:18:20 PM     Points: 5094    
Me and Kastmasters are a waste of time. NEVER caught a fish on it. Tried it ice fishing for lakers...nada. Trout snub me when I cast it their way. Panther Martins are way nicer to me!
 Reply by: chodeman      Posted: May. 16, 9:52:04 PM     Points: 705    
Plugs and stickbaits for trout are my nemesis. Ironic, because they can be my go to baits for walleye and bass!
 Reply by: Gurnman      Posted: May. 16, 11:54:32 PM     Points: 234    
Its been a long time since i caught something on a rooster tail.... used them as a kid all the time cuz thata what my dad gave me to use and id catch one now and then. Now i cant get a bite.

Crawdad hard baits also never work for me either.
 Reply by: Fishinbud      Posted: May. 17, 12:26:56 PM     Points: 0    
Goosehunter82, you have got to try jigging raps in the winter (tipped with a head/tail of minnow or gulp), even now when over a school of fish, and especially in the fall, it's often a go-to lure. For you, it could easily go from worst, to dam near 1st.
 Reply by: Fishneveryweek      Posted: May. 17, 2:03:13 PM     Points: 33    
I could throw everything in all my tackle boxes in the lake and only fish with bait rigs. And I wouldn't miss the lures at all. Still I am obsessed with dragging them around to whatever lake I fish. Just doesn't make sense!
 Reply by: SirGreg88      Posted: May. 19, 4:32:54 AM     Points: 56    
I agree. lures are the devil. Expensive and worthless. Cursed actually. Oh and any of that copycat bait by Zeke's. I don't fish bait often but when I do-its not with that stuff.
 Reply by: Assassin      Posted: May. 19, 6:59:06 AM     Points: 1044    
Johnski, I have a love hate with kastmasters. I find fish have to be aggressive for them to work for me. Tipping them ice jigging doesnt hurt either. All the same, I dont use them much. Panther martins work better for me too, I think because you can retrieve them super slow or fast and they still spin great. Love those guys.

I think jerkbaits are my nemesis. I keep buying them. I keep throwing them. And it seems like everytime I give them a go I get skunked.
 Reply by: shiverfix      Posted: May. 19, 8:47:11 AM     Points: 3761    
johnski, it is just the opposite for me. Love kasties, have caught both fresh and salt on them. But I can cast a spinner until my arm falls off with no luck.

Then again, I probably wouldn't cast one until my arm fell off. I think that one lure that doesn't work for us is the lure we don't have any confidence in so we give up on pretty quick. Self fulfilling prophecy.. See, I knew it wouldn't work, I'm going back to a (fill in the blank with your favorite lure here).
 Reply by: Fishneveryweek      Posted: May. 19, 12:55:09 PM     Points: 33    
I once had a chance to do a sort of controlled experiment: I went to a lake loaded with 12 -14 inch cutthroats that did not allow bait fishing, but which had so many fish in it that you could catch them on just about anything. So, I decided this would be a good chance to see what lure worked the best. I stood in one place on a big rock where I could cast 180 degrees and I took my collection of lures that I had the most faith in (what little faith I did have in them), and I tried them one after the other for equal number of casts to see what got the most hits. I had panther martins, Thomas lures, Kastmasters, and I forget all what else. Bottom line was the Kastmaster took the prize by about a factor of about two. A couple weeks later, they drained the lake and killed all the cutts - typical irrigation district indifference to the fish. At least I discovered something interesting before that happened. Later on, with other lakes for cutts, I gave fly and bubble fishing a shot, and that proved better than lures, but less predictable.
 Reply by: johnski      Posted: May. 19, 2:33:01 PM     Points: 5094    
Yea could be a bit of self-fulfilling prophecy. I like they way Kastmasters will cast WAAAYY out in a horrendous wind, and you can fish lots of water. But still no fish for me!
 Reply by: Smelly      Posted: May. 19, 2:59:43 PM     Points: 23731    
Gotta agree with Pathway. To a point. Most lures will catch fish . Yes throw a lure often enough . And odds are something will bite it. That doesn't make the lure productive or unproductive. Just not suited to the way a person likes to fish.Or not suited to the fish in the area. Some people like to reel fast . some like to slow retrieve. Some like to twitch and reel, some don't . And the truth is. The avg fisherman .. doesn't .. change their retrieve enough to match their lure.And lets face it. If a lure doesn't produce. You loose confidence in it . And it rarely gets used.

Im just as guilty. I like to paint lures.I like to experiment with different patterns I got a whole box full of '"Killer" lure patterns That DON"T CATCH FISH. Why don,t they catch ? There based off of popular patters , and use popular colors and my standard lures . The fish here just don't relate to them. Doesn't mean that in different waters . Or fished often enough ,they won't produce. They just didn't work well enough for me. So I quickly loose confidence in them. And they end up in my "rejection " box. Besides , my feelings get really, really hurt, When my lure passes by a fish . And he sticks his head out of the water , puts his fins in his ears and goes ..pppphhbbbrrrrttttt !!!!!!

Also for the record. For me it's Super Dupers. I can't seem to get a retrieve on those lures that will even get a fish to sniff it. One of the most popular trout lures on the planet. And I can't seem to work it. People swear by them , I swear at them ! When I'm fishing one . I can even hear the fish giggling as my lure passes them.
 Reply by: ass bass or cash      Posted: May. 19, 5:04:17 PM     Points: 1730    
I think we all learned alot here. My cursed lure is your go-to and vice versa. There is something to be said about fishing certain lures in the right conditions, with the right action, retrieval speed and for the right species. Ultimately, when fish are hungry, they bite! See guy who catches catches catfish on egg mcmuffin or bluegil on literally anything.
 Reply by: bron      Posted: May. 19, 6:11:04 PM     Points: 36517    
I know a guy like that!
 Reply by: Team CO.F.F.      Posted: May. 19, 6:14:58 PM     Points: 27    
God I wish my buddy used this forum, he has a lipless crankbait that is a painted to look exactly like a clownfish...We've tossed it around a few times for fun, never a nip LOL.
 Reply by: skiman      Posted: May. 19, 7:04:00 PM     Points: 2326    
bron...Iím pretty sure I know who youíre talking about!
(ďThe MasterĒ)
 Reply by: mxtsinclair      Posted: May. 21, 5:36:31 AM     Points: 72    
Ass Bass or Cash - I was reading some old posts and came across this picture from Musky5150. Check out the lure....theres hope! haha
 Reply by: anglerwannabe      Posted: May. 21, 8:08:35 AM     Points: 56749    
HHHEEEYYYYYY!!! That looks almost like he's at LongDraw Reservoir!

 Reply by: brookieflyfisher      Posted: May. 21, 3:48:02 PM     Points: 6130    
As has been said, most every lure will catch fish eventually, or given the right situation. For me, it's more technique-based.

The Carolina rig has never caught me a bass. It's partially a lack of trying, for sure, but still, there have been plenty of tournaments won and lots of bass caught by the C-rig. Not a single fish for me.

I've also never caught a bass on a rat-l-trap or any of the copycats. Caught plenty of pike and walleye on em though.

Spybaiting has also never worked for me, but I'm sure I haven't really found the situation in which it will shine. Those lures are too dam expensive to not work!! In the same vein, I have a couple jointed swimbaits that haven't seen the inside of a fish's mouth.

The drop shot and ned rig are a couple more techniques that definitely do not work as well for me as for other people. To be fair, this one is 100% because of personal preference. I've caught plenty of fish with these techniques. I'm just not a finesse fisherman and I don't like fishing them. I have a hard time staying in contact with the bait, I don't like wading through all the small fish and non-target species, and I don't like the constant battle with snags and break-offs.
 Reply by: ass bass or cash      Posted: May. 21, 6:37:46 PM     Points: 1730    
Mxtsinclair - that's a great fish. First I've seen on that style lure. Thanks for sharing!
 Reply by: ark angler      Posted: May. 22, 2:10:41 PM     Points: 380    
Itís a jakes spin o lure. Take it to Yellowstone lake about this time of year. I caught over 50 Yellowstone cutthroat in a morning on that lure. They really didnít want any other lure...

Back to top...