Fish Explorer Logo
Colorado Fishing
Colorado Fishing  
Login Usr:Psd:
No account? Register now...
spacer spacer
Go back to Main FxR Forum listings
River: Roaring Fork River - Middle
Fish: Rainbow Trout

Where'd all the brown trout go--Roaring Fork 5-17-15

Post By: brookieflyfisher      Posted: 5/18/2015 12:01:16 AM     Points: 6196    
Went out to the Roaring Fork with my dad to try to get some fishing done before runoff.

Stayed Friday night at the Aspenault lodge in Basalt. Woke up this morning, got the good word from the Taylor Creek Fly Shop, and got to work upstream of Basalt.

Water clarity was alright and flows were still pretty wadable. It is difficult to cross the river wading. Bug life is incredible, tons of cased/uncased/netmaking caddis, BWOs, drakes, and golden stones crawling around on the rocks. BWO hatches started up around mid-morning and continued on through to the afternoon. Not enough bugs to get fish on the surface (I tried). There were also some caddis flying around in the afternoon/evening, but according to other people a lot less than two weeks ago before the beginning of runoff.

The fish were picky. Tried stones and worms to start. Caught only one brown on the stones, which in my experience is very unusual for the Fork. Usually there are plenty of fish willing to eat stoneflies. We switched to caddis, caddis emergers, and attractor nymphs, which picked up a few fish. After that some BWOs started flying around so I probably tried 5 or 6 different types of BWO emerger patterns with limited success. It seemed like every fish bit a different fly. The best flies were a Formerly Known as Prince in sz. 14 and a Flashback PT in sz. 16-20. Fish would bite on the swing occasionally but most were on the dead drift. Fish were all over the water column, but fish holding over shallow rocks in seams and flatwater seemed to be more aggressive than the fish holding down deep.

Hooked around 20 total, landed 10. I don't know why I missed so many. My dad got 2, hooked and lost a few more. 10 of the landed fish were rainbows, only 2 were browns. Most of the fish I hooked and lost were also rainbows. That Hofer stocking program is either paying off or displacing a great brown fishery, depending on your perspective.

As always a fantastic weekend in the Roaring Fork Valley. It's my favorite river in CO, and I can't wait to go back!

The Eagle and Gore Creek still looked low and clear, so there are still plenty of places to fish over the next week or two before we see runoff. Enjoy the pics!
 Reply by: brookieflyfisher      Posted: 5/18/2015 12:07:30 AM     Points: 6196
 Reply by: Dakota Dude      Posted: 5/18/2015 8:41:13 AM     Points: 2571
Great pictures! Sounds like an awesome weekend. It must just be where you were fishing. I fished the dirty water around Carbondale last week, caught 20-25 and only about 5 were bows. Caught a lot of browns in that 17-20 inch range. Hooked a mountain white as well.
 Reply by: brookieflyfisher      Posted: 5/18/2015 7:58:26 PM     Points: 6196
Wow Dakota that's a great day, more similar to the other days I've had on the Fork. Throwing stones and worms in that muddy water or were you trying to match that BWO hatch?
 Reply by: Dakota Dude      Posted: 5/18/2015 8:38:59 PM     Points: 2571
Ha I wanted to until I figured it out! When it's muddy water like that with those kind of flows it helps to fish shallow and use something dark and shiny!
 Reply by: slicedog      Posted: 5/19/2015 7:04:22 AM     Points: 91
Did you try any streamers? I was there on the 9th around snowmass and the browns destroyed the black double gongas . It was a pretty epic streamer day.
 Reply by: brookieflyfisher      Posted: 5/20/2015 9:00:46 AM     Points: 6196
I did try a white streamer for a few minutes and didn't get anything.
Operation Game Thief
Call to report illegal fishing/hunting:
Email CPW